There are refeeds, diet breaks, and free meals. What is the difference between all of these? When should some of these be utilized? What are the pros and cons of each?
Diet Breaks
Diet breaks were recently discussed in an issue of MASS (Monthly Applications in Strength Sports). The title of the article was "Diet Breaks Make an Energy Deficit More Effective and Less Costly" and was written by Eric Helms. Diet breaks were first popularized by Lyle McDonald during 2005 in his book, "A Guide to Flexible Dieting." In this study by Eric Helms, two groups of obese men were studied. One group maintained a 33% energy deficit diet (67% of maintenance energy) non-stop for 16 weeks, whereas the other group took a two-week diet break after every two weeks of dieting, although their diet lasted 30 weeks total.
The study found that during the diet breaks, the obese men neither gained nor lost any body weight. The study also discovered that the group that took diet breaks lost approximately 50% more fat mass and body weight, but had only half the reduction in resting energy expenditure when compared to the group that dieted non-stop without diet breaks. During a follow-up to the study, it was shown that the group that dieted non-stop without taking diet breaks regained more body fat than that diet break group. This finding provides evidence that taking diet breaks allows for greater maintenance of body fat levels after a dieting period. During this period of a diet break, the individual will raise their calories back up to maintenance level.
In his book, "A Guide to Flexible Dieting," Lyle McDonald describes more reasons to take a full diet break, stating that it fulfills both physiological and psychological needs. For the psychological need, a diet break cuts your diet into smaller pieces that are easier for an individual to maintain in over the full course of their diet. This way, their "dieting efforts" are split up into parts (McDonald). For physiological needs, the increase in calories also increases metabolism and leptin.
Free/Cheat Meals
This is a single meal that is used in your diet. Since it is only one meal, it does not have the capability to effect or alter the hormone levels. Instead, the purpose of free/cheat meals is more psychological and aids in adherence to dieting in the long-term (McDonald).
Refeeds
A reefed is defined as "a brief overfeeding period in which caloric intake is raised slightly above maintenance levels, and the increase in caloric intake is predominantly achieved by increasing carbohydrate consumption" (Trexler). The purpose of these refeeds during dieting periods is to momentarily increase circulating leptin and increase the metabolic rate (Trexler). Previous evidence has shown that leptin is sensitive to "short-term overfeeding" and is "highly correlated with carbohydrate intake" (Trexler).
Happy eating,
Ashley Storm
Helms, Eric. "Diet Breaks Make an Energy Deficit More Effective and Less Costly." Monthly Applications in Strength Sport, 2017.
McDonald, Lyle. A Guide to Flexible Dieting. 1st ed., 2005.
Trexler, Eric T, et al. "Metabolic Adaptation to Weight Loss: Implications for the Athlete." Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, vol. 11, no. 1, 27 Feb. 2014, doi:10.1186/1550-2783-11-7.
Diet Breaks
Diet breaks were recently discussed in an issue of MASS (Monthly Applications in Strength Sports). The title of the article was "Diet Breaks Make an Energy Deficit More Effective and Less Costly" and was written by Eric Helms. Diet breaks were first popularized by Lyle McDonald during 2005 in his book, "A Guide to Flexible Dieting." In this study by Eric Helms, two groups of obese men were studied. One group maintained a 33% energy deficit diet (67% of maintenance energy) non-stop for 16 weeks, whereas the other group took a two-week diet break after every two weeks of dieting, although their diet lasted 30 weeks total.
The study found that during the diet breaks, the obese men neither gained nor lost any body weight. The study also discovered that the group that took diet breaks lost approximately 50% more fat mass and body weight, but had only half the reduction in resting energy expenditure when compared to the group that dieted non-stop without diet breaks. During a follow-up to the study, it was shown that the group that dieted non-stop without taking diet breaks regained more body fat than that diet break group. This finding provides evidence that taking diet breaks allows for greater maintenance of body fat levels after a dieting period. During this period of a diet break, the individual will raise their calories back up to maintenance level.
In his book, "A Guide to Flexible Dieting," Lyle McDonald describes more reasons to take a full diet break, stating that it fulfills both physiological and psychological needs. For the psychological need, a diet break cuts your diet into smaller pieces that are easier for an individual to maintain in over the full course of their diet. This way, their "dieting efforts" are split up into parts (McDonald). For physiological needs, the increase in calories also increases metabolism and leptin.
Free/Cheat Meals
This is a single meal that is used in your diet. Since it is only one meal, it does not have the capability to effect or alter the hormone levels. Instead, the purpose of free/cheat meals is more psychological and aids in adherence to dieting in the long-term (McDonald).
Refeeds
A reefed is defined as "a brief overfeeding period in which caloric intake is raised slightly above maintenance levels, and the increase in caloric intake is predominantly achieved by increasing carbohydrate consumption" (Trexler). The purpose of these refeeds during dieting periods is to momentarily increase circulating leptin and increase the metabolic rate (Trexler). Previous evidence has shown that leptin is sensitive to "short-term overfeeding" and is "highly correlated with carbohydrate intake" (Trexler).
Happy eating,
Ashley Storm
Helms, Eric. "Diet Breaks Make an Energy Deficit More Effective and Less Costly." Monthly Applications in Strength Sport, 2017.
McDonald, Lyle. A Guide to Flexible Dieting. 1st ed., 2005.
Trexler, Eric T, et al. "Metabolic Adaptation to Weight Loss: Implications for the Athlete." Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, vol. 11, no. 1, 27 Feb. 2014, doi:10.1186/1550-2783-11-7.

Comments
Post a Comment