Skip to main content

Do I Need to Reverse Diet

I'm done with my show/prep and I'm READY TO EAT EVERYTHING. I just want to eat all the things. Should my plan be to bring my calories up to maintenance and eat the way I used to before my prep/diet? No, I don't think that's the best idea.

Introduction
Chances are, after your prep, you've lost a significant amount of weight. Along with weight loss comes a hefty amount of metabolic adaptations that work to promote weight regain and minimize the  energy deficit you've put yourself in. I'm not just talking about physique sports such as bodybuilding preps either - I'm also talking about cuts for wrestling, gymnastics, figure skating, and other sports where low body fat and/or a lean body mass is required.
Your body's job is to keep you alive, and technically, it believes that you are starving and requires more food. Your metabolism thus adapts by improving its efficiency, decreasing your energy expenditure, and increasing the body's cues for energy intake (Trexler). Ultimately, your metabolism is going to slow down.

Major Players
Your thyroid plays a major part in your body's adaptations to the diet phase. Research shows that increases in the amount of circulating thyroid hormones, especially triiodothyronine, are related to an increase in metabolism, whereas decreased thyroid levels are associated with decreased thermogenesis and overall metabolism (Trexler). Leptin is another important hormone involved in metabolism. The hormone leptin is made in the adipocytes and is an indicator of short and long-term energy availability (Trexler). Research shows that lower body fat levels and short-term energy restriction are related to decreases in the amounts of circulating leptin, whereas higher amounts of leptin are related to increases in energy expenditure and satiety (Trexler).
Insulin works to stop the breakdown of muscle proteins and normalize macronutrient metabolism. Individuals with high levels of insulin are provided with signals that they have good energy availability and this high concentration is associated with an anorexigenic effect. An anorexigenic effect is a decrease in appetite --> decreased food consumption --> weight loss. Grehlin is the orexigenic hormone (increase appetite --> weight gain).
Overall, studies have shown that low calorie diets lead to a reduction in metabolic rate, increased hunger, and ultimately pose a threat to the maintenance of lean mass (Trexler).

Energy Expenditure
Another way the metabolic rate is effected through dieting is through alterations in energy expenditure. Total daily expenditure (TDEE) is made up of multiple different components. The biggest component of TDEE is the resting energy expenditure (REE), which refers to the basal metabolic rate (BMR). The second big component is non-resting energy expenditure (NREE), which is further broken down into non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT), exercise activity thermogenesis (EAT), and the thermic effect of food (TEF). I found a really great image from the paper that demonstrates all the parts of TDEE, shown below!


(Trexler)

During a weight loss phase, an individual's TDEE decreases. Additionally, there is a decrease in metabolically active tissues, and thus a decrease in BMR (basal metabolic rate). Research has described the extreme drop in TDEE as "adaptive thermogenesis" and explains that it works to promote the restoration of baseline body weight (Trexler). Interestingly, adaptive thermogenesis aids in the explanation of the common weight regain after a weight loss and weight loss plateaus during caloric deficits (Trexler).
Exercise activity thermogenesis is also decreased during and after periods of weight loss. Non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT) is predictably decreased during periods of weight loss, as the subject is usually tired and not as prone to move around and fidget.

What to Do About This
In order to maintain weight after all these adaptations occur, the energy intake of the individual must be adjusted based on the energy expenditure. Energy expenditure is complicated by the alterations to TDEE, TEF, NEAT, EAT, and BMR. One study describes that "in the period shortly after cessation of a restrictive diet, body mass often reverts toward pre-diet values. This body mass is preferentially gained as fat mass" (Trexler). This means that after your diet/prep has ended, your body wants to return to it's previous, pre-diet weight. In order to do this, it will put on fat very quickly if given the chance. Even after the diet is over, it takes a while for hormones and metabolic adaptations to recover, so a "dramatic increase in energy intake [at this time] results in rapid accumulation of fat mass" (Trexler). This phenomenon is termed "overshooting," where the individual increases their body fat levels beyond baseline, although their metabolic rate remains at a low level. To avoid this quick fat gain following the end of a diet or prep, a reverse diet can be implemented.

Reverse Dieting: Conclusions
Reverse dieting is the process of increasing an individual's calories incrementally. Overall, there has not been much scientific research on reverse diets, but as you can see from above, there has been some research on metabolic adaptations to dieting. Due to these metabolic adaptations, your maintenance calories (the amount of calories it takes to maintain your body weight) is much lower than what it was before your diet. This makes sense as you now have a lower body weight - a smaller body does not require as much energy. A smaller body also does not expend as much energy doing activities. An example helps to clarify this: it is very difficult for a bear to run a half-marathon, and he would burn a lot of calories doing it, whereas it would be much easier for a mouse to run the half-marathon and he would not use as much energy (burn as many calories) doing this exercise. You cannot increase your calories to your "pre-diet" intake and expect to maintain your new physique. You must take into account the adaptations your body has made and give it time to recover. One of the major ways to recover from metabolic adaptations is to increase body fat, given it is at a very low level after a competition. You do not want to "overshoot," so it would be wise to bump up your calories to a NEW calculated maintenance, then slowly increase your calories incrementally from that point. I do not suggest maintaining an extreme calorie deficit much longer than necessary and very slowly reverse dieting, as this will just extend the time your body is under stress.

Stay smart,
Ashley Storm


Trexler, Eric T, et al. "Metabolic Adaptation to Weight Loss: Implication for the Athlete." Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, vol. 11, no. 1, 27 Feb. 2014, p. 7., doi:10.1186/1550-2783-11-7 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Athletes: The Supplement You Need to Be Taking

You've heard about creatine and protein powder. You've heard about glutamine and omega-3 supplementation, among many more. But I'm going to go over a very important supplement that I see nearly every physique athlete (and I imagine many athletes) neglecting to use: IODINE. Why is iodine important? How do you get it?

Refeeds, Diet Breaks, Free Meals?

There are refeeds, diet breaks, and free meals. What is the difference between all of these? When should some of these be utilized? What are the pros and cons of each?